As one of your frequent debate partners and iron sharpeners, I can vouch for the fact that whether we agree or not (and we DISagree on a fair amount even though we agree on much), you have always treated me with respect and as an intellectual equal. We have some of the best conversations ever, and while we might not change our opinion, I think we both leave the convo thinking more about our own positions. Sometimes you have to be challenged to better refine your argument, and that's part of the beauty of the debate itself. So far, I haven't seen you ever be a jerk to someone who engages you in good faith.
The problem is that few people engage in good faith. ;)
I am grateful that I was a member of my high school debate team. Formal, competitive debate requires debaters to argue alternately both the pro and the con of a proposition. To this day, I believe that formal debate (not the crap that politicians engage in) is the most effective way to learn. If I can’t debate with myself, I shall remain hopelessly ignorant.
I think you missed a key point in evaluating many arguments you encounter. Johnathan Swift says it best. Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired."
As one of your frequent debate partners and iron sharpeners, I can vouch for the fact that whether we agree or not (and we DISagree on a fair amount even though we agree on much), you have always treated me with respect and as an intellectual equal. We have some of the best conversations ever, and while we might not change our opinion, I think we both leave the convo thinking more about our own positions. Sometimes you have to be challenged to better refine your argument, and that's part of the beauty of the debate itself. So far, I haven't seen you ever be a jerk to someone who engages you in good faith.
The problem is that few people engage in good faith. ;)
What Nietzsche DID say, which hardly anyone remembers today, is "If you can't dance, you shag a lot of waitresses."
I am grateful that I was a member of my high school debate team. Formal, competitive debate requires debaters to argue alternately both the pro and the con of a proposition. To this day, I believe that formal debate (not the crap that politicians engage in) is the most effective way to learn. If I can’t debate with myself, I shall remain hopelessly ignorant.
I think you missed a key point in evaluating many arguments you encounter. Johnathan Swift says it best. Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired."